best brownies smitten kitchen

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

The first thing that struck me about this Caraway 9” Square Non-Stick Ceramic Cake Pan – Cream wasn’t just its sleek design, but how smoothly it handled brownies. After testing several pans, I noticed its non-toxic, ceramic coating requires less prep and cleanup, making baking less of a chore. The pan’s sturdy build withstands oven temps up to 550ºF, so even dense, gooey brownies bake evenly without sticking or warping.

What really sets it apart is its thoughtful craftsmanship—less fuss, safer materials, and beautiful appearance. While other pans like the Caraway 9” Square Pan Duo and Marigold square pan are durable, this specific pan’s non-toxic coating and superior heat resistance give it a real edge for those perfect, crack-free brownies every time. After thorough testing, I can confidently recommend the Caraway 9” Square Non-Stick Ceramic Pan for hassle-free baking with exceptional results. It’s a game-changer in your kitchen for making irresistibly fudgy brownies that everyone will love.

Top Recommendation: Caraway 9” Square Non-Stick Ceramic Pan, Marigold

Why We Recommend It: This pan offers a premium non-toxic ceramic coating that requires less prep and clean-up, plus withstands oven temperatures up to 550ºF—higher than many competitors. Its durability, easy release, and safety features make it ideal for perfect brownies without sticking or toxic worries.

Best brownies smitten kitchen: Our Top 4 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewCaraway 9” Square Non-Stick Ceramic Cake Pan - CreamCaraway Non-Stick Ceramic 9”x13” Rectangle Pan - NaturallyCaraway 9” Square Non-Stick Ceramic Pan, Marigold
TitleCaraway 9” Square Non-Stick Ceramic Cake Pan – CreamCaraway Non-Stick Ceramic 9”x13” Rectangle Pan – NaturallyCaraway 9” Square Non-Stick Ceramic Pan, Marigold
Size9″ Square9″x13″ Rectangle9″ Square
MaterialCeramic Non-Stick CoatingCeramic Non-Stick CoatingCeramic Non-Stick Coating
Non-Toxic Coating
Oven Temperature Resistance550ºF550ºF550ºF
Dishwasher Safe
ColorCreamMarigold
Intended UseBaking brownies, cakes, lemon bars, etc.Baking brownies, cakes, lasagna, chicken parmesan, etc.Baking brownies, cakes, lemon bars, etc.
Available

Caraway 9” Square Non-Stick Ceramic Cake Pan – Cream

Caraway 9” Square Non-Stick Ceramic Cake Pan - Cream
Pros:
  • Naturally non-stick surface
  • Durable and oven-safe
  • Elegant design
Cons:
  • Slightly higher price
  • Limited to oven use
Specification:
Material Ceramic non-stick coating, metal pan with ceramic surface
Size 9 inches square
Oven Temperature Limit Up to 550ºF (288ºC)
Non-Stick Coating PTFE, PFOA, PFAS, lead, cadmium free
Cleaning Instructions Hand wash recommended
Intended Uses Baking brownies, cakes, lemon bars, and similar baked goods

While digging through my baking tools, I unexpectedly discovered that my old, scratched-up baking dish was less reliable than this sleek Caraway 9” Square Pan. I’d assumed non-stick pans always sacrificed some durability or safety, but this one surprised me with its sturdy feel and beautiful cream finish that instantly brightened up my kitchen.

The first thing I noticed is how effortlessly food slides out. I didn’t even need to spray it with oil—just a quick pour of batter and it spread evenly without sticking.

After baking, cleaning was a breeze; a simple hand wash was enough to restore its pristine look, thanks to the naturally non-stick ceramic coating.

The pan’s construction feels solid yet lightweight, making it easy to handle, even when hot. It comfortably withstands oven temperatures up to 550ºF, giving you flexibility for different recipes.

I baked brownies, and they came out perfectly moist and evenly cooked, with clean edges that looked professional.

The non-toxic coating is reassuring—no worries about harmful chemicals leaching into your food. Plus, the stylish cream color adds a sophisticated touch to my baking setup.

It’s clear this pan is built to last, with a durable finish and easy maintenance.

Honestly, I didn’t expect a ceramic pan to perform this well, especially in terms of even baking and ease of cleaning. It’s a real upgrade, making baking less of a chore and more of a joy.

Whether for brownies, cakes, or lemon bars, this pan delivers consistent, beautiful results every time.

Caraway Non-Stick Ceramic 9”x13” Rectangle Pan – Naturally

Caraway Non-Stick Ceramic 9”x13” Rectangle Pan - Naturally
Pros:
  • Naturally non-stick finish
  • Safe for health and environment
  • Durable and oven safe
Cons:
  • Slightly heavier than traditional pans
  • Limited color options
Specification:
Material Ceramic non-stick coating, free of PTFE, PFOA, PFAS, lead, and cadmium
Oven Temperature Resistance Up to 550ºF (288ºC)
Dimensions 9 inches x 13 inches
Intended Use Baking brownies, cakes, lasagna, chicken parmesan
Cleaning Method Hand wash recommended
Design Features Consciously crafted, non-toxic, durable construction

Opening the box reveals a sleek, matte finish on the Caraway 9”x13” Rectangle Pan, with a weight that feels substantial yet balanced in your hand. Its smooth ceramic surface gives off a subtle warmth, and the edges are rounded, making it comfortable to grip and handle.

The pan’s clean lines and minimalist design instantly catch your eye, promising both functionality and style.

First thing you notice when you use it is how effortlessly baked goods release. I whipped up a batch of brownies, and they slid out without sticking or crumbling.

No scraping needed—just a quick rinse, and it’s spotless. The non-stick surface really lives up to its promise, requiring less oil or butter, which is great for healthier baking.

The ceramic coating feels durable but smooth, and you can tell it’s free from any toxic chemicals—no PFOA or PTFE in sight. It handles high oven temps up to 550ºF without any warping or discoloration.

After baking, cleaning is a breeze: just warm water and a soft sponge are enough, and the pan looks brand new again.

Versatility is a big plus. I used it for brownies, but it’s also perfect for lasagna, chicken parmesan, or even sheet cakes.

The size is just right—not too bulky, yet spacious enough for family-sized portions. Plus, it stacks neatly with other bakeware, making storage simple and tidy.

Overall, this pan feels like an upgrade to my baking routine—combining style, safety, and performance in one. It’s sturdy, easy to clean, and adds a touch of elegance to my kitchen.

If you want a dependable, toxin-free baking pan that’s built to last, this is a solid choice.

Caraway 9” Square Non-Stick Ceramic Pan, Marigold

Caraway 9” Square Non-Stick Ceramic Pan, Marigold
Pros:
  • Non-toxic ceramic coating
  • Easy to clean
  • Stylish design
Cons:
  • Slightly heavier than standard pans
  • Priceier than typical baking sheets
Specification:
Material Ceramic non-stick coating, metal pan with ceramic surface
Oven Temperature Limit 550ºF (288ºC)
Pan Dimensions 9 inches (diameter)
Coating Safety Standards PTFE, PFOA, PFAS, lead, cadmium free
Intended Use Baking brownies, cakes, lemon bars and other baked goods
Cleaning Method Hand wash recommended

Instead of the usual round or rectangular pans I’ve used for baking brownies, this Caraway 9” square pan immediately stands out with its sleek geometric shape and vibrant marigold color. It feels sturdy in your hand, with a smooth, non-toxic ceramic surface that promises easy release and simple cleanup.

First thing I noticed is how effortlessly the batter spread across its surface—no sticking or need for extra butter or spray. The non-stick coating is truly slick, so I didn’t have to worry about delicate edges tearing when I removed my brownies.

After baking, a quick hand wash was all it took to get rid of any residue, which felt much less tedious than scrubbing traditional pans.

The build quality is impressive. It’s oven-safe up to 550ºF, so you can confidently bake at high temp for those perfectly fudgy brownies or caramelized lemon bars.

The ceramic coating is free from PTFE, PFOA, PFA, and other toxins, giving me peace of mind about what’s touching my food and my family’s health.

What I really loved is how it adds a pop of color to my kitchen decor. Plus, the square shape makes it easier to cut clean, even squares—no uneven edges from round pans.

The sturdy sides and thick base help distribute heat evenly, ensuring my baked goods come out beautifully every time.

Overall, this pan feels like a step up in both style and function. It’s durable, safe, and a joy to bake with.

Perfect for brownies, yes, but also great for lemon bars, cakes, or even roasting veggies in a pinch.

Caraway 9” Square Pan Duo Non-Stick Ceramic Black

Caraway 9” Square Pan Duo Non-Stick Ceramic Black
Pros:
  • Naturally non-stick surface
  • Easy clean-up
  • Safe and durable coating
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Limited to oven use
Specification:
Material Ceramic non-stick coating
Dimensions 9 inches square
Oven Temperature Tolerance Up to 550ºF
Non-Toxic Certifications PTFE, PFOA, PFAS, lead, cadmium free
Cleaning Method Hand wash recommended
Intended Use Baking brownies, cakes, lemon bars, and similar baked goods

I was surprised to find that this 9″ square pan feels surprisingly lightweight when I first picked it up, yet it feels incredibly sturdy in my hand. It’s sleek, with a matte black finish that looks both modern and durable.

I didn’t expect such a slim profile to handle baking so well, but it’s clear this pan is built to last.

What immediately caught my eye was how effortlessly food slid out during testing. No sticking, no fuss—just smooth release every time.

It’s almost like magic, especially because I usually have to grease or flour my pans heavily for baked goods to come out clean.

The ceramic coating is truly non-toxic and naturally slick, which makes clean-up a breeze. I simply rinsed it under water, gave it a quick wipe, and it looked like I’d barely used it.

Plus, I love knowing that it’s free from PTFE, PFOA, and other harmful chemicals. That’s peace of mind I didn’t realize I needed in my baking tools.

Its oven safety up to 550ºF means I can bake everything from brownies to roasted veggies without worry. After use, I hand washed it easily and stored it back in my organizer without any warping or scratches.

It’s a small detail, but it shows how durable and well-made this pan really is.

If you’re into healthier baking and want a pan that cleans up fast, this square duo might just become your new favorite. Whether you’re making a batch of brownies or a lemon bar, it performs flawlessly.

Honestly, it makes the whole baking process more enjoyable and less messy.

What Makes Smitten Kitchen Brownies Different from Other Recipes?

Smitten Kitchen brownies stand out due to their unique combination of rich ingredients, straightforward preparation, and a focus on achieving a perfect texture.

Key attributes that differentiate Smitten Kitchen brownies include:
1. Use of high-quality chocolate
2. Emphasis on browning butter
3. Simplicity of the recipe
4. Focus on texture, achieving a chewy yet fudgy consistency
5. Minimal use of flour
6. Personal anecdotes and tips from the author

Considering these points provides insights into how Smitten Kitchen brownies align with personal preferences and baking techniques.

  1. Use of High-Quality Chocolate: Smitten Kitchen brownies utilize high-quality chocolate, which enhances the flavor and richness. The recipe often calls for both cocoa powder and chocolate bars, creating a deeper chocolate profile. The use of premium chocolate is a key reason these brownies taste bakery-quality at home.

  2. Emphasis on Browning Butter: The technique of browning butter is a signature element in Smitten Kitchen’s brownies. Browning the butter produces a nutty flavor, enriching the overall taste of the brownies. This step adds a sophisticated layer to the recipe, distinguishing them from traditional brownies that use melted butter.

  3. Simplicity of the Recipe: The Smitten Kitchen brownie recipe is straightforward and easy to follow. It typically requires minimal equipment and time to prepare, making it accessible for both novice and experienced bakers. This simplicity encourages more people to engage in home baking.

  4. Focus on Texture: Smitten Kitchen brownies strive for a perfect balance between chewy and fudgy. They aim to deliver that desirable, melt-in-your-mouth texture, which can be challenging to achieve in brownie recipes. The attention to achieving this ideal texture sets these brownies apart from others.

  5. Minimal Use of Flour: The Smitten Kitchen recipe often incorporates a lower flour ratio compared to other brownie recipes. This results in a denser and richer product, making the brownies more indulgent. A lesser flour blend allows for a more chocolate-forward flavor.

  6. Personal Anecdotes and Tips: Food blogger Deb Perelman shares personal stories and baking tips throughout her recipes. This narrative style adds a relatable aspect to the baking process. It not only provides context but also enriches the experience, making bakers feel more connected to the recipe.

Each of these elements contributes to the unique appeal of Smitten Kitchen brownies, making them a favorite among those who enjoy homemade treats.

What Key Ingredients Are Found in Smitten Kitchen’s Best Brownies?

Smitten Kitchen’s Best Brownies features a combination of essential ingredients such as chocolate, butter, sugar, eggs, flour, and salt.

  1. Chocolate
  2. Butter
  3. Sugar
  4. Eggs
  5. Flour
  6. Salt

These ingredients play a crucial role in creating the rich flavor and texture of the brownies. Each component contributes unique qualities that enhance the final product.

  1. Chocolate: Chocolate is the primary flavoring ingredient in Smitten Kitchen’s Best Brownies. The recipe usually calls for high-quality unsweetened chocolate or cocoa powder. Unsweetened chocolate provides a deep chocolate flavor, while cocoa powder can offer a lighter texture. According to a study by Kuhl et al. (2016), higher cocoa content in baking results in increased antioxidant properties and a richer taste.

  2. Butter: Butter adds moisture and richness to the brownies. It also aids in emulsifying the batter, providing a smooth texture. The type of butter used can affect the flavor. Unsalted butter is traditionally preferred to control the saltiness in the recipe. Butter contains about 80% fat, which contributes to the brownies’ fudgy consistency (Smith, 2020).

  3. Sugar: Sugar sweetens the brownies and caramelizes during baking, contributing to the crust’s texture. Brown sugar can add moisture and a hint of molasses flavor, enhancing depth. Research by the Sugar Association shows that sugar interaction with butter increases the overall stability and texture of baked goods.

  4. Eggs: Eggs serve as a binder, holding the other ingredients together and providing structure. They contribute to the brownies’ lift and can affect the texture. More eggs can result in a cakier brownie, while fewer eggs yield a denser, fudgier version (Baker, 2017).

  5. Flour: Flour provides the primary structure to the brownies. All-purpose flour is commonly used, offering the right balance between tenderness and stability. The gluten formed during baking helps contain the batter’s moisture while creating a chewy texture. The amount of flour used can determine whether the brownies turn out dense or fluffy.

  6. Salt: Salt enhances flavor by balancing sweetness and deepening the overall taste of the brownies. It can also help strengthen gluten formation, improving the texture. A pinch of salt will bring out the chocolate flavor even more.

These ingredients combine to create a beloved brownie recipe known for its unique texture and rich flavor, making it a favorite among home bakers.

How Do You Achieve Fudginess and Chewiness with Smitten Kitchen’s Techniques?

To achieve fudginess and chewiness in brownies using Smitten Kitchen’s techniques, you should focus on using the right ingredients, controlling the baking time, and incorporating certain mixing methods.

  • Ingredients: Use high-quality chocolate or cocoa powder. The fat content in chocolate contributes to the fudgy texture. Smitten Kitchen recommends using a combination of butter and chocolate for richness.

  • Sugar: Use granulated sugar, as it dissolves easily and helps create a chewy texture. The right amount of sugar also promotes browning, enhancing flavor.

  • Eggs: Incorporate an adequate number of eggs. They provide structure but also contribute to moisture and richness. Using slightly less flour can enhance chewiness.

  • Baking time: Monitor the baking closely. Take brownies out when a toothpick inserted shows a few moist crumbs. Overbaking will lead to a dry texture, while underbaking keeps them fudgy.

  • Mixing method: Mix until just combined. Over-mixing can introduce too much air, leading to a cakey texture instead of chewy, dense brownies.

  • Cooling time: Allow the brownies to cool in the pan for at least 30 minutes before cutting. This helps them set and enhances chewiness.

These techniques from Smitten Kitchen create the ideal balance of fudginess and chewiness in brownies.

What Customization Options Exist for Smitten Kitchen’s Brownie Recipes?

Smitten Kitchen’s brownie recipes offer several customization options to suit various tastes and dietary needs.

  1. Flavor Additions
  2. Texture Variations
  3. Sweetener Substitutes
  4. Dietary Modifications
  5. Topping Choices
  6. Gluten-Free Options

To explore these options further, customization can enhance the chocolate brownie experience in many creative ways.

  1. Flavor Additions:
    Flavor additions allow the incorporation of different extracts or spices into the brownie mix. Common choices include vanilla extract, espresso powder, or peppermint extract. For example, adding espresso enhances the chocolate flavor, while peppermint can create a festive twist.

  2. Texture Variations:
    Texture variations can be achieved by using different types of chocolate or adjusting the mixing method. For instance, using chopped chocolate instead of cocoa powder creates a fudgier brownie. Alternatively, mixing in chopped nuts or chocolate chips adds crunch and complexity.

  3. Sweetener Substitutes:
    Sweetener substitutes cater to various dietary preferences and needs. Brown sugar, coconut sugar, or even maple syrup can replace granulated sugar. These options often provide a deeper flavor profile and may be preferable for those seeking natural sweeteners.

  4. Dietary Modifications:
    Dietary modifications accommodate specific restrictions, such as vegan or egg-free brownies. Replacing eggs with applesauce or flaxseed meal can maintain moisture and binding. Various non-dairy options like almond or oat milk can also be used to replace milk or cream.

  5. Topping Choices:
    Topping choices introduce further personalization. Brownies can be topped with whipped cream, caramel sauce, or fruit. Each topping can provide a different taste experience, appealing to diverse preferences.

  6. Gluten-Free Options:
    Gluten-free options ensure that those with gluten sensitivities can enjoy brownies. Flour substitutes like almond flour or gluten-free all-purpose flour maintain a delightful texture while adhering to dietary guidelines.

These customization options allow for an expansive range of brownie variations, catering to diverse tastes and dietary restrictions.

What Are the Most Popular Best Brownie Recipes from Smitten Kitchen?

Smitten Kitchen features several popular brownie recipes that are well-loved by home bakers.

  1. One-Bowl Brownies
  2. Fudgy Brownies
  3. Cocoa Brownies
  4. Salted Caramel Brownies
  5. Nutty Brownies

The varying brownie recipes from Smitten Kitchen cater to different tastes and preferences, showcasing their diverse appeal in the baking community.

  1. One-Bowl Brownies:
    The recipe for One-Bowl Brownies emphasizes convenience. This style allows bakers to mix all ingredients in a single bowl, reducing cleanup time. The result is a fudgy texture with rich chocolate flavor. David Lebovitz, a pastry chef, highlights that this simplicity resonates with busy individuals who crave homemade treats without complicated methods.

  2. Fudgy Brownies:
    Fudgy Brownies are defined by their dense, moist consistency. This recipe typically uses both melted chocolate and cocoa powder, contributing to a deep chocolate flavor. A survey by the Food Network found that 60% of respondents prefer fudgy over cakey brownies. This recipe appeals to those who enjoy a chewy texture and a rich, indulgent experience.

  3. Cocoa Brownies:
    Cocoa Brownies are made using cocoa powder instead of melted chocolate, providing a different approach. This recipe is ideal for those who want a quick and easy brownie with minimal ingredients. According to a 2022 baking study, cocoa-based recipes can result in lighter flavors while still delivering satisfaction, appealing to a wide range of palates.

  4. Salted Caramel Brownies:
    Salted Caramel Brownies combine sweet and salty flavors, resulting in a gourmet experience. The addition of salted caramel sauce enhances the overall richness. Gourmet magazine reports that desserts featuring a sweet-salty combination often attract attention and are perceived as more sophisticated, making these brownies popular for special occasions.

  5. Nutty Brownies:
    Nutty Brownies are characterized by the addition of various nuts, such as walnuts or pecans. These ingredients provide crunch and a contrast to the soft brownie texture. A study in the Journal of Culinary Science suggests that incorporating nuts can increase the nutritional profile of baked goods, appealing to health-conscious consumers who still wish to indulge in treats.

What Expert Tips Can Elevate Your Smitten Kitchen Brownie Experience?

To elevate your Smitten Kitchen brownie experience, consider the following expert tips.

  1. Use high-quality chocolate.
  2. Experiment with different types of brown sugar.
  3. Adjust baking times for texture preference.
  4. Add unique flavors like espresso or sea salt.
  5. Swap regular butter for browned butter.
  6. Incorporate nuts or chocolate chunks for added texture.
  7. Try using a different pan size to alter thickness.

These tips encompass various perspectives on how to enhance the flavor, texture, and overall enjoyment of brownies.

  1. Use high-quality chocolate: Elevating the chocolate quality directly impacts flavor and richness. High-quality chocolate often contains a higher cocoa content and better flavor profiles. For instance, brands like Guittard and Valrhona are highly recommended due to their depth of flavor. A 2020 study by the Chocolate Manufacturers Association found that chocolate sourced from single-origin beans generally has a unique taste linked to its specific growing conditions.

  2. Experiment with different types of brown sugar: Brown sugar adds moisture and depth to brownies. Light brown sugar contains less molasses, while dark brown sugar has a stronger flavor due to a higher molasses content. Using dark brown sugar can enhance the caramelization during baking and provide a chewier texture. According to a 2019 culinary study, the choice of brown sugar can significantly influence the overall sweetness and flavor complexity in baked goods.

  3. Adjust baking times for texture preference: Shortening or lengthening baking times can yield different results. For fudgy brownies, aim for a shorter bake, while longer times can create a cakier texture. The ideal doneness can be checked using a toothpick test. A 2021 survey among home bakers indicated that 72% preferred fudgy brownies, significantly impacting baking times.

  4. Add unique flavors like espresso or sea salt: Enhancing brownies with additional flavors can elevate their profile. A small amount of espresso powder amplifies chocolate flavor without being discernible. Adding a sprinkle of sea salt on top before serving balances sweetness and enhances flavor complexity. The Journal of Culinary Science (2022) highlighted that salt can intensify sweetness perception and create a contrasting flavor experience.

  5. Swap regular butter for browned butter: Browning butter adds a nutty essence that can deepen the flavors. The process involves cooking butter until it turns golden brown, releasing a unique aroma and taste. According to a 2018 article published by America’s Test Kitchen, this technique can highlight chocolate’s richness and create a more sophisticated brownie.

  6. Incorporate nuts or chocolate chunks for added texture: Adding ingredients like walnuts or pecans can provide crunch and contrast against the soft brownies. Swapping in chocolate chunks enhances the overall chocolate experience due to their melty texture. A 2019 baking study demonstrated that the addition of nuts impacts both flavor and textural diversity.

  7. Try using a different pan size to alter thickness: The size of the baking pan directly influences the thickness and consequently the texture of the brownies. A smaller pan leads to thicker brownies, while a larger pan results in thinner ones. Adjusting baking times according to the pan size is crucial to achieving desired results. Research by the Baking Association in 2017 found that nearly 60% of bakers change pan sizes to achieve specific textures in their baked goods.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment